Jump to content

Collisions


Jeb KerBoom

Have you hit something in orbit?  

2 members have voted

  1. 1. Have you hit something in orbit?



Recommended Posts

Only had one. I had managed to get the maincore for my station up into orbit and put the leftover fueltanks and rockets on a deorbit path. I then proceeded to launch a module of habitats etc. During my ascend stage, I could see a fireball coming in my direction, ramming the mainsail on one of my outter fueltank and tearing it off. I quickly separated the fueltanks and managed to get it to orbit. The stage I had to drop was just about empty anyway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Had my first actual accidental collision between two separate craft today. Also the only docking I've ever ruined after the fact (no, I didn't quicksave either). I guess 20 or 30m at an angle isn't enough clearance to start retrofire when you have NERVAs and solar panels, among other things, sticking out on those extra-long struts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was trying to dock with another space craft in orbit of Kerbol... And I had my direction right on the money, unfortunately, I was going a bit fast. I saw the distance continue to drop, I still couldn't see it very well, and then *BOOM* Both were in pieces... Why must I be so accurate?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah I have.

My first operation on a new save is a satellite in a 80-100k circular equatorial orbit. My usual procedure is a three stage rocket, a launch stage, an orbital stage, and a circulation stage. The launch stage wet beautifully, the orbital stage put it rather oblong but otherwise smoothly. I had waited till I was close to periapsis and ejected the orbital stage. I then set up to lower the apoapsis to a circular orbit. This set up required going retrograde.

Perfect retrograde.

Did I forget to mention that when I ejected the orbit stage i was at perfect prograde?

So I fired up the engine and whoops! You know the martial arts "one inch punch?" This was essentially the orbital space equivalent.:blush:

Lesson learned, point the ejection part AWAY from where you will fire to (preferably straight down to the planet), THEN eject!:sticktongue:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've had only two encounters with debris.

The first was a strut end, which fell off because of that weird glitch where putting them attached to bicouplers makes the ends decouple and float around, which came within a paltry 5.6km.

The other was the entire second stage of one of my KW launch vehicles, which I had jettisoned immediately after using it to get a close intercept with a station. A few orbits later the entire thing, which is like 10 meters tall and weighs 17 tons dry, smacked right into the middle of my station at about 75m/s closing speed. No more station after that :(

The bottom part of this rocket is the second stage. It's in 3.75m diameter, so it's fairly large on its own.

58OVkEG.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have to report this, it's crazy. I've experienced a collision during early stages of rendezvous in Duna orbit after a successful manned landing mission. This never happened to me away from Kerbin.

This is the lander I used.

mars1_1.png

mars1_7.png

It didn't have enough fuel to reach orbit, so I've established a stable orbit using RCS. Barely.

The tug ship was in a much higher orbit so I've lowered it down to catch the lander. This wasn't during the RCS phase. The lander simply turned from a point in the distance to a large explosion, smashing into the tug, ending in a roughly same orbit after this energy transfer. :confused:

mars1_9.png

It happened so fast, I've almost forgot to take a screenshot.

Surprisingly, the only damage was to the lander itself. One busted bipropellant and one RCS round tank.

mars1_10.png

I've managed to return Bob and Bill to Kerbin, making this my first manned mission to Duna and back.

mars1_11.png

They almost crashed into Kerbin because one of the parachutes had a problem. They almost died few times during this mission.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've had both high and low energy collisions. One of the more spectacular was when a piece of on-rails-for-ages debris from a failed mission to the outer solar system managed to plow through the middle of a space station, with predictable results.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I was first trying to dock I slammed into my target at 30 m/s. Haven't had any random orbital collisions though, despite every mission afterwards having to fly out through the equatorial debris belt left by that collision.

EDIT:

And I have at least once, undocked, lined up with a target on the nav ball and then floored it straight into the thing I just undocked from.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a perfect encounter with my station and ended up within 200 meters of it. I started thrusting towards the station and then decided to decouple my last stage and continue using just RCS. Just as I was about to dock I saw the stage coming towards the station. I aborted the docking and tried to get to it and bump it out of the way before it hit the station but I didn't make it. It took out half the station. I was lucky that no Kerbals were in the wrecked sections and I was able to rescue them. Another time during launch I ran into an orange tank that was left in a lower orbit. I've also knocked off panels while approaching for docking and took out a couple of panels with Kerbals doing EVA. One time the panel was just sitting there a few meters away and I wished I could have grabbed it with the Kerbal and reattached it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not hit anything in orbit (excluding docking errors) but did have a piece of debris in an elliptic come very, very close (<<200m) at very high relative speed while assembling my space station. That brought back the risks and prompted a clean up of near Kerbin orbits. Now take even more care to avoid leaving spent stages flating around, and any debris that misfortune leaves in orbit is a high priority to be hunted down and de-orbited.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nope, I had close encounters with orbiting debris, but never hit anything (in the latest versions of KSP I always ensure that spent stages either get decoupled at altitudes that let them fall back to Kerbin, or at orbits that don´t endanger anything that is in orbit (or pollute the orbit I frequently use as staging point for my spacecraft ... which is around 100-125 km)).

Don´t want to have any scenarios like the one in gravity happen :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I was learning to dock, I got this really nice .1km intercept from launch. But during my circularization burn, I lost all controls and the navball spazzed out. I switched out of map view to see nothing left of either ship but a huge cloud of debris. It turns out that 1 km/s docking doesn't work so well.

I've had more orbital collisions than I care to remember, but that one really stands above the rest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This thread is quite old. Please consider starting a new thread rather than reviving this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...