I'll give credit where credit is due. The STS was visionary that incorporated a lot of forward thinking engineering and scientific goals which in turn advanced the breadth and depth of our knowledge about space and space travel. You could argue that it inspired generations of boys and girls to take up an interest in STEM fields. That said I have a hard time justifying it's existence in retrospect. They promised a space truck which was massively oversold on capabilities that never quite materialized for a market that wasn't even there. It wasn't very cost efficient and it wasn't so much reusable as it was refurbishable. To be fair a lot of overhead was added due to the dozens of groups with conflicting goals trying to get a piece of the action. There were a lot of requirements from different factions, such as the Air Force's insistence that it be able to launch spy satellites into a polar orbit from Vandenberg AFB. Because of this it ended up really having to pack a lot of complexity and capability into one machine on a budget and certain safety considerations ended up being thrown out. For what it's worth, I think we would have been better off sticking to a Soyuz-like craft for carrying people to and from LEO. Existing Titan and Delta launchers could have been used to send up the big space station bits like the Russian Protons. This way we have a clear separation of mission roles and less complexity allowing for things to go wrong. After all there's no sense in taking a multi-tool to do a specific job when all we needed was a screwdriver. I'm also a big fan of Big Gemini and think that it might have been a good choice for crew and resupply missions to stations and even orbital construction yards, serving in a similar capacity as TKS for Salyut. It would have had that capability to carry 9 or 12 people depending on configuration and would be roughly the same mass as an Apollo capsule, but would carry twice the cargo to LEO. And this was without the proposed cylindrical cargo module, which would've increased cargo capacity even further.