Looks like I have to step in here... Even though no rules have been expressly broken, this thread has generate a lot of controversy and I can't see it getting any better going forward. Now, packs of addons have been done before, the most famous of which is the Novapunch pack, but these were put together by modders either working together on the pack or the creator of the parts was contacted and their permission was granted before inclusion. Over time Squad has had to update and add to the rules here, including those for addons, and we all need to abide by the wishes of modders when using or redistributing their works. If a modder doesn't want his stuff shared around and changed, he can release it as All Rights Reserved, this is in fact the defacto standard license if no other can be found. So what does this mean for modpacks? It means they aren't impossible or unwelcome but permission has to be granted for every addon that is a part of it, and just as with the addon rules, the licenses for all parts must be present in both the zip and on the forum page where it can be found. Of course, with something as complex as a pack, it becomes necessary to have proof of permission as well, so there will need to be a file showing permission from all contributors, ideally it should be part of the license(s). So that's where we are now and where this thread comes to an end, by all means make modpacks, but only if all contributions are permitted by the addon license or permission is expressly given by the modder. And do this before any release.